Roth vs. Traditional 401(k): How to Choose
With a traditional 401(k) you get a tax deduction now and pay tax when you withdraw. With a Roth 401(k) you pay tax now and withdraw tax-free. Both grow the same way inside the account, so the question is simply which tax rate is lower: the one you pay now or the one you’ll pay in retirement.
Compare them. Enter your tax rates in the Roth vs. traditional 401(k) calculator.
The simple rule
- If you expect a higher tax rate in retirement than today, Roth tends to win.
- If you expect a lower rate, traditional tends to win.
- If the rates are the same, the two come out about even.
An example
You’re in the 24% bracket and can put in $10,000 before tax. A traditional contribution is $10,000. A Roth contribution costing the same take-home pay is $7,600, because $2,400 goes to tax. After 25 years at 7%, the traditional account is worth about $54,300 and the Roth about $41,200. If you withdraw the traditional money at a 22% rate, you keep about $42,300, slightly more than the Roth. At 32%, you’d keep about $36,900, so the Roth wins. Change the numbers in the calculator.
Limits for 2026 and 2027
You can contribute up to $24,500 in 2026 and $25,500 in 2027 across Roth and traditional 401(k) contributions combined, plus catch-up contributions if you’re 50 or older. Check your plan for its options, and for how catch-up contributions are treated: starting in 2026, higher earners’ catch-up contributions generally must be made as Roth.
Things that tilt the decision
- You’re early in your career and expect your income, and tax rate, to rise: Roth.
- You’re at your peak earning years: the deduction from traditional contributions is worth more.
- You want tax diversification: splitting between the two gives flexibility in retirement.
- You’ll hit the limit: a Roth shelters more after-tax value for the same dollar limit.
- Employer match: usually goes in pre-tax, whichever type you choose for your own contributions.
- State taxes: if you plan to retire in a state with no income tax, traditional looks better.
It isn’t forever
You can change the choice every year. Money already in a traditional account can later be moved with a Roth conversion, and you can add a Roth IRA alongside your 401(k): see how to open a Roth IRA.